Custodial Torture

Shivendra Pratap Singh


High Court Lucknow


Reading Time:

Custodial torture in India is a grave human rights issue that involves the abuse and mistreatment of individuals while in police custody. It is a violation of their fundamental rights and is considered a serious criminal offense. Despite constitutional safeguards and legal provisions in place, custodial torture continues to persist, highlighting the need for greater awareness, accountability, and systematic reforms within the criminal justice system.

Forms of Custodial Torture

Custodial torture can take various forms, including:

  1. Physical Abuse: This includes beatings, use of excessive force, and other forms of physical violence intended to coerce confessions or punish individuals.
  2. Psychological Abuse: Torture is not limited to physical harm; it can also involve psychological torment, such as threats, intimidation, or sleep deprivation.
  3. Sexual Abuse: Regrettably, custodial rape is a distressing reality in some cases, where police officers sexually assault detainees in their custody.
  4. Deprivation of Basic Needs: Detainees may be denied access to food, water, and medical care as a means of exerting control and pressure.

Legal Framework to Prevent Custodial Torture:

The Indian Constitution and various international conventions provide safeguards against custodial torture. Some notable legal provisions include:

  1. Article 21: The right to life and personal liberty enshrined in the Indian Constitution protects individuals from torture and cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment.
  2. The Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993: This legislation establishes the National Human Rights Commission and State Human Rights Commissions, which play a crucial role in investigating human rights violations, including custodial torture.
  3. The Criminal Procedure Code, 1973: Section 41D makes it mandatory for police officers to inform detainees of their rights, including the right to be examined by a medical officer, and to record any injuries on their bodies.
  4. The Indian Evidence Act, 1872: Confessions obtained under custodial torture are not admissible as evidence in court.

Challenges and Impediments:

Despite the existence of laws and guidelines to prevent custodial torture, several challenges hinder their effective implementation:

  1. Lack of Awareness: Many individuals are not aware of their rights and the legal protections available to them, leaving them vulnerable to abuse in custody.
  2. Weak Implementation: Weak enforcement of existing laws, coupled with inadequate training and oversight, contributes to the persistence of custodial torture.
  3. Impunity: In some cases, perpetrators of custodial torture evade accountability due to inadequate investigations, delays in legal proceedings, and a lack of witness protection.
  4. Reluctance to Report: Fear of reprisals and a lack of trust in the system often discourage victims or witnesses from reporting incidents of custodial torture.

Addressing Custodial Torture

To combat custodial torture effectively, comprehensive measures are needed:

  1. Police Reforms: Strengthening and modernizing the police force through training and capacity-building can foster a more professional and accountable law enforcement agency.
  2. Independent Oversight: Establishing independent oversight mechanisms to investigate complaints of custodial torture can ensure impartial investigations and deter misconduct.
  3. Sensitization and Training: Raising awareness about human rights and sensitizing law enforcement officials on the legal consequences of custodial torture is crucial.
  4. Victim Support and Rehabilitation: Providing support and rehabilitation to victims of custodial torture is essential to help them heal physically and psychologically.
  5. Swifter Justice: Fast-tracking cases involving custodial torture and ensuring timely legal proceedings can enhance deterrence and build public confidence in the justice system.

Custodial torture is a reprehensible violation of human rights and a blight on the criminal justice system in India. Addressing this issue requires collective efforts from the government, civil society, and law enforcement agencies. By implementing effective measures, raising awareness, and holding perpetrators accountable, India can work towards eradicating custodial torture and upholding the principles of justice and human rights.